SPONSORS
2024 ICRBE EXPO |
Can you REALLY repair a broken graphite rod?
Posted by:
Tony Hill
(---.ras11.vahen.tii-dial.net)
Date: February 21, 2002 02:12PM
I've read here and there that broken rods can be repaired, but I've never met anyone that can do it. Is this just fantasy and heresay, or is there really a way to do it? I'm guessing the answer is no, but I figured I'd ask first! TH ABSOLUTELY!
Posted by:
Bill Falconer
(65.116.172.---)
Date: February 21, 2002 02:19PM
Tony- Depending on the severity of break and where it is, the answer to your question more often than not is YES - most rods can be repaired. If it is completely shattered you may not have much of a chance, but if it is a relatively intact break or split it can usually be fixed. Ralph O'Quinn is the best I've seen at this. I was as skeptical as you are until I sent a few his way that I thought were beyond hope. He fixed them up good as new (although you could tell they had been repaired). If you look at back issues of Rodmaker, several types of breaks and their respective fixes have been detailed. I'm sure others here can give you info on the specific issues. There are also several threads in the history that pertain to breaks and their repairs if you want to take a shot at fixing it yourself. If you are looking for someone else to fix it, check out tackleworks.org - it's a site that has state-by-state listings of repair people. You should be able to find one near you. I hope this helps - good luck! Bill Re: ABSOLUTELY!
Posted by:
Tony Hill
(---.ras11.vahen.tii-dial.net)
Date: February 21, 2002 02:28PM
INTERESTING! So cracked or split rods have a chance, one that is broken in two is, pretty much done as far as being returned to a similar state to pre-break? I've seen a "repair" where a blank was "sleeved" inside the broken rod, but in my opinion, the rod became so heavy, and the flex was so impaired, that it was nothing you would want to fish with. What makes me ask, is that I broke a rod pulling an anchor rope up against a current. The rod simply snapped about 1/3 the way from the tip. I hated when that happened. Was a great rod, but I cannot see a way to repair such a break without sleeving the rod, and therefore ruining the action. TH Re: ABSOLUTELY!
Posted by:
Dwayne Rye
(---.wff.nasa.gov)
Date: February 21, 2002 02:38PM
In a couple of back issues of Rod Maker There are indepth articles that discuss the How To's in repairing the rod. These articles not only discuss putting the rod back together, but how to put it back together and maintain the same action and feel. I've repaired rods similar to where your rod is broke and the action has not been effected, or to be more accurate with my statement, is VERY close to the action and feel the rod had prior to the break. I would have to say that most rods can be repaired quite nicely, if the individual making the repair uses the proper repair materials, and follows a few simple techniques. Re: ABSOLUTELY!
Posted by:
Mark Schulte
(---.tnt3.valparaiso.in.da.uu.net)
Date: February 21, 2002 03:14PM
I have been waiting to try to repair a broken rod but the ones that keep coming my way are destroyed. I mean like shattered, splinters all over the place. I have even considered snapping a few of my older ,out of service rods and try to repair. I want to put it under load like most anglers would to the point of breaking so it would be a fair comparison. Am I being ridiculous or have others done this. Mark Schulte Re: ABSOLUTELY!
Posted by:
Tony Hill
(---.ras11.vahen.tii-dial.net)
Date: February 21, 2002 03:34PM
"I mean like shattered, splinters all over the place." That is what my rod is like... shattered. TH Yes, it can be repaired
Posted by:
Tom Kirkman
(---.dialsprint.net)
Date: February 21, 2002 04:55PM
It can still be repaired with the proper technique. The only real limit as to what can be repaired lies more with how much time and effort you are willing to put into it. The January/February 2000 issue of RodMaker has Ralph's article. It is the best thing I have yet seen on the subject. .................. Re: Yes, it can be repaired
Posted by:
Dick Thurston
(---.midtn.chartertn.net)
Date: February 21, 2002 11:06PM
You will be surprised how little the "sleeving" effects the action of the rod and they actually add only a slight amount of weight. While you can tell by looking where the repair was made it is not objectionable in appearance. I refinished the sleeves the same color as the blank (or use a sleeve of the same color) & no problem. The sleeved area becomes the strongest part of the rod & should never cause another problem. Re: Yes, it can be repaired
Posted by:
Rolly Beenen
(---.ym.rnc.net.cable.rogers.com)
Date: February 23, 2002 11:06AM
If you go to flyanglersonline.com and go to their rod building site you will find the Ralph O'Quinn article on rod repair. This is the article that was in Rodmaker Mag. and posted there with permission from Tom and Ralph. Rolly Re: Yes, it can be repaired
Posted by:
Andy
(---.proxy.aol.com)
Date: March 02, 2002 12:01AM
All I know what to do if you have a broken graphite rod is to turn it into a jigging stick for ice fishing (if you live where you can ice fish safely). Cut the broken part of the rod with the tip top to the desired lenght. Glue on a cork grip with two sliding rings to mount the reel. Remove any guides that are close to the grip if you need to. Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
|