SPONSORS
2024 ICRBE EXPO |
Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Fon Tze
(---)
Date: February 12, 2023 01:04PM
Hey fellas, just a popularity question to satisfy my own curiousity:
For those that build steelhead drift rods (float/bobber/bobber dogging etc), do you build more spinning or casting rods? Best Fon Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Kerry Hansen
(---.wavecable.com)
Date: February 12, 2023 07:26PM
Casting Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Spencer Phipps
(---)
Date: February 12, 2023 07:29PM
A drift rod is a bank presentation and has no floating device keeping your gear off the bottom, you are drifting in the current and ticking bottom or you are not fishing. I prefer casting rods but do have a few summer run low water spinning rods. Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Kendall Cikanek
(---)
Date: February 12, 2023 08:12PM
I see more people spinning with drift bobbers on Oregon coastal rivers by quit a bit. Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Stan Daubinawski
(---)
Date: February 12, 2023 10:02PM
Adding to this question. As someone who hasn't gone steelhead fishing before. What length do you recommend for a rod of this type? I wouldn't be doing this in PNW but rather in WI for Great Lakes tributaries "Steelhead". Thanks Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Kendall Cikanek
(---)
Date: February 12, 2023 10:44PM
My answer varies based on bank fishing, wading, or drift boat fishing. I’d go 9’ in a boat, 9’6” on the bank, and more than 10’ wading. I’ve both fished and been a management biologist for steelhead in the PNW and the Great Lakes basins. Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Spencer Phipps
(---)
Date: February 12, 2023 10:47PM
Those northern WI streams that are faster and hold the fairly rare Lake Coho I used the shorter 8 1/2 - 9 ft. rods from the PNW due to the smaller and steeper gradient streams. Being stationed in MI I never fished any WI streams for steelhead, the MI streams I fished were big enough and clean banked enough for 10 1/2 ft. rods to help extend my drifts, these were built for Canadian waters. Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 02/12/2023 11:00PM by Spencer Phipps. Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Joel Wick
(66.115.181.---)
Date: February 12, 2023 10:53PM
Stan Daubinawski Wrote:
------------------------------------------------------- > Adding to this question. As someone who hasn't > gone steelhead fishing before. What length do you > recommend for a rod of this type? I wouldn't be > doing this in PNW but rather in WI for Great Lakes > tributaries "Steelhead". Thanks 10'-11' would be a good starting point for a spinning, casting, or centerpin rod used for floats. Longer, perhaps for fishing the larger rivers, but certainly not a requirement. Most here use centerpins and spinning rods because of the lighter tackle and finesse used as compared to West Coast steelheaders. Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Kendall Cikanek
(---)
Date: February 13, 2023 12:33AM
In my mind we are all saying the same thing in slightly different ways. In a drift boat the person at the stern is rowing and steering the boat. This leaves fishing and netting in a 16-18 foot boat in the bow to center positions. This makes any rod in the 10’ or more range cumbersome for landing/netting duties. I see the NFC 962x-2 the best hardware blank made for steelhead float fishing, but would go longer for big rivers and wading if clearance is available. Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Spencer Phipps
(---)
Date: February 13, 2023 01:17AM
In a boat where I was using plugs I would be using 7 1/2 to 8 ft. rods. Side drifting is what we call drifting with or without a float in a boat with the current, not the same as drift fishing, the 962x-2 is an excellent choice in or out of a boat and would work excellent in the slower current flows of the Midwest all seasons and fish to 20 lbs. I would think. Hook size #8 to #2. Spinners #2 to #5, Spoons to 1/2 oz. (IM) blanks lose little to an (HM) blank in a boat, especially if you are using floats and it gives a decent uptick in durability, rarely will you see guides with HM rods. Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Kendall Cikanek
(---)
Date: February 13, 2023 02:12AM
Spencer’s inferences are the same as mine on every point. Guides do usually go for durability and value over the top level of performance. Side drifting has been waning in comparison to float bobber fishing for the last several years, but it’s still a very effective way to catch steelhead. There is more to being effective with these fishing methods than the rod one chooses. I’ve experienced epic and challenging days relative to fishing buddies. Feel, observation, and timing are important. All take practice and focus. Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Stan Daubinawski
(---)
Date: February 14, 2023 09:26PM
Thanks for input. Ordered a NFC ST-962x blank. Hopefully can get in time to try fishing for steelhead this spring. Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Mike Ballard
(---.ip-167-114-11.net)
Date: February 15, 2023 12:50PM
We don't do steelhead drifting down here but we do drift for other species. It is my feeling that casting outfits offer certain advantages when drift fishing. I feel that you have better control of line-out and adjustments as you need them. And when needed line counter casting reels offer something you cannot get with a spinning set up. These are just my thoughts based on what we do in the SE. Your type of fishing might be so different that nothing I have offered would do you any good. Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
roger wilson
(---)
Date: February 15, 2023 04:11PM
Fon,
Casting or spinning? It is a toss up. Both methods have advantages and disadvantages. With todays rods, reels and line - it is really not important. Both will do a great job of hooking and landing fish. Take your choice and enjoy the ride. Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Kendall Cikanek
(---)
Date: February 16, 2023 09:41AM
Spinning is best if you have challenging casting elements such as a float rig with a lot of hinge or overhanging vegetation. I prefer mending the drift and boat landing big steelhead on a casting reel, though. A big, wild hatched hen can do things up close that is best saved by thumb modulation on an otherwise free spool. It’s difficult for spinning drags to allow the angler to prevent extreme rod angles while maintaining a taught line. That blank can be built either way and many big steelhead have been boat landed on spinning gear. Re: Popularity question: spinning vs casting steelhead drift?
Posted by:
Stan Daubinawski
(---.sub-174-194-97.myvzw.com)
Date: March 24, 2023 11:16AM
Follow Up Question: On my rods that are 7-7.5 Ft long I have around a 10.75" Reel to Butt Length because that is where I like the butt to hit my forearm above my elbow.. This does result sometimes in a slightly tip heavy rod, but I have never added any weights to the butt to compensate for this and it has been fine to cast all day. But with a longer rod used for Steelhead and similar Handle length it might be too tip heavy.. Do I add a weighted butt or something to try to balance it a little so that you can keep the line up easier while fishing and not result in fatigue? Or go to a longer handle(Which seems to negate the use of a longer rod). Or just accept a little more tip heavy rod. (As I haven't done steelhead fishing before I don't have a basis of reference)
Thanks, Stan Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
|